MLB The Show 26 All-Time Teams EXTREME challenges your Diamond Dynasty squad across 39 games, from three-inning matchups against individual clubs to a nine-inning meeting with the MLB All-Time Team. A well-built roster can help, but spending MLB Stubs is only one part of preparation: lineup depth, patient hitting, and careful pitching decisions matter throughout the program.
How the Missions Add Up
The program contains 39 missions worth a total of 160 program points. Each mission lists a requirement to get one stat, while its group description specifies defeating the opposing team. Play for the win and check the mission screen for progress afterward rather than assuming that any single in-game statistic completes it.
The first six groups cover the 30 individual clubs. Every game lasts three innings and awards four points, for 20 points per division and 120 points across all six groups.
The next group features six divisional All-Time Teams in six-inning games. The NL East mission awards five points; the other five award four each, bringing the group total to 25. The last group contains three nine-inning games against the American League, National League, and MLB All-Time Teams, with five points available from each.
Plan the Club Matchups
Short games leave little time to recover from a mistake. Put hitters you trust near the top of the order, since they are more likely to receive an early plate appearance. A lineup with several reliable contact options can also help keep an inning moving when a single home run does not provide enough offense.
Use the division groups to keep track of progress and decide what to play next.
• AL East: Orioles, Red Sox, Yankees, Rays, and Blue Jays.
• NL East: Braves, Marlins, Mets, Phillies, and Nationals.
• AL Central: White Sox, Guardians, Tigers, Royals, and Twins.
• NL Central: Cubs, Reds, Brewers, Pirates, and Cardinals.
• AL West: Astros, Angels, Athletics, Mariners, and Rangers.
• NL West: Diamondbacks, Rockies, Dodgers, Padres, and Giants.
Work through one division at a time if keeping track of completed opponents is difficult. Between games, inspect the mission screen for unfinished entries so that a missed result does not send you into a repeat matchup by mistake.
Turn Short Games in Your Favor
In a three-inning game, an early baserunner can change the entire contest. Avoid swinging at the first pitch automatically; look for a pitch in a location you can handle, and make the pitcher throw strikes. With two strikes, protect the plate while staying alert for pitches outside the zone.
Defensively, prioritize clean outs over risky throws. If a runner has a clear path to an extra base, forcing a difficult play can turn one runner into a bigger inning. Take the out available when the safer choice keeps the opposing lineup from gaining additional opportunities.
Adjust your approach to the situation.
• With a runner on base and no outs, focus on a hittable pitch instead of forcing a stolen-base attempt.
• With a narrow lead, watch pitcher performance closely and prepare a replacement if command or pitch quality becomes a problem.
• When trailing late, use available bench options for a favorable matchup, while keeping their defensive positions in mind.
• After a missed scoring chance, return to patient at-bats; chasing pitches to recover quickly often creates easier outs.
Prepare for Longer Games
The six-inning divisional games provide more room to adjust, but they also demand attention beyond the first few innings. If an opposing pitcher keeps retiring hitters with the same pitch, watch its location and timing before changing your swing approach. Review the score and upcoming hitters before using a bench player, especially if that substitution creates a weak defensive position later.
For the three nine-inning games, enter with a roster you can manage over a full contest. Consider which pitchers can cover different situations and which reserve hitters offer useful alternatives. A close game can turn on a late pitching change or a defensive replacement, so avoid using every option before the matchup calls for it.
Keep upgrades focused on gaps that affect your play, such as a position where your current hitter struggles or a pitching option you do not trust. If you decide to use MLB The Show Stubs on a roster addition, choose a player who fits that need, then take the revised squad into the next unfinished matchup.